What Should I Look for When Shopping at Mattress Stores?

What Should I Look for When Shopping at Mattress Stores?


How do I determine which mattress type is right for me?

Choosing the right mattress starts with understanding the different types available and how each one supports your body. Personal preferences, body type, and sleep position all influence the best fit for you.

1. Know the Main Mattress Types

There are several common mattress types:

Type Material Composition Key Benefits
Innerspring Steel coils with foam or fiber Supportive, affordable, breathable
Memory Foam Polyurethane foam Contouring, pressure relief
Latex Natural or synthetic latex Responsive, eco-friendly, durable
Hybrid Coils + memory foam/latex Balance of support and comfort
Airbeds Adjustable air chambers Customizable firmness

Understanding these categories is the first step in narrowing down your choices.

2. Consider Your Sleep Position

Your preferred sleep position affects how a mattress should feel.

  • Back sleepers: Medium-firm is usually ideal.

  • Side sleepers: Softer mattresses reduce pressure on shoulders and hips.

  • Stomach sleepers: Firmer beds help maintain spinal alignment.

  • Combination sleepers: Responsive or hybrid beds work best.

3. Factor in Body Weight

Body weight impacts how deeply you sink into a mattress and how well it supports your spine.

Weight Range Recommended Mattress Type
Under 130 lbs Softer mattresses
130–230 lbs Medium to medium-firm mattresses
Over 230 lbs Firmer or hybrid mattresses

Heavier individuals benefit from more durable and supportive surfaces like latex or hybrids.

4. Understand Firmness Levels

Firmness is subjective but typically rated from 1 (softest) to 10 (firmest). Most people prefer something between 5 and 7 for balanced support. Try lying on mattresses in-store to determine your comfort zone.

5. Assess Motion Isolation

If you share your bed with a partner, motion isolation is key. Memory foam and latex tend to excel in absorbing movement, preventing nighttime disruptions.

6. Evaluate Cooling Features

Some mattresses trap heat, which can disturb your sleep. Look for:

  • Gel-infused memory foam

  • Open-cell or perforated latex

  • Coil systems that promote airflow

  • Breathable covers

Cooling technologies are especially important for hot sleepers.

7. Consider Allergies and Materials

Natural latex, organic cotton, and wool are hypoallergenic options. Avoid low-quality foams that off-gas and trigger sensitivities.

8. Take Lifestyle Into Account

Do you need edge support to get in and out of bed? Do you watch TV or read in bed? Hybrid mattresses and those with reinforced edges or adjustable bases may suit your lifestyle better.

9. Try Before You Buy

Take your time testing mattresses. Lie on each one for 10–15 minutes in your usual sleep positions. Don’t feel pressured to rush — comfort is subjective and worth evaluating carefully.

10. Trust Your Body

No amount of research replaces how a mattress feels to you. Let your body guide the decision and use your store visit as an opportunity to align your needs with what feels right.

What should I ask the salesperson when visiting a mattress store?

Walking into a mattress store can feel overwhelming, but asking the right questions can help you make a smart and satisfying purchase. Salespeople are there to guide you, and knowing what to ask ensures you’re getting the full picture.

1. What mattress types do you carry, and what are their differences?

Start by asking for a breakdown of the various mattress types in the store. This helps you understand what’s available and which ones align with your needs. A knowledgeable salesperson should explain the pros and cons of innerspring, memory foam, latex, hybrid, and specialty mattresses.

2. Which mattress is best for my sleep position?

Tell the salesperson whether you sleep on your back, side, stomach, or a combination. They can recommend mattresses that support spinal alignment and pressure relief based on your position.

3. What firmness level would suit my needs?

Firmness preferences vary by individual. Ask about how each mattress feels and request firmness ratings (typically on a 1–10 scale). Let the salesperson guide you through mattresses that match your comfort zone.

4. Can I try the mattress before purchasing?

Always ask if you can lie on the mattress in-store. A good store will encourage you to try several models for at least 10 minutes each. Some even offer private test areas to ensure you feel relaxed.

5. What’s included in the warranty?

Warranties differ widely. Ask:

  • What does the warranty cover (sagging, defects)?

  • How long does it last?

  • Are there conditions that void the warranty?

Here’s a quick comparison of typical warranties:

Brand Type Average Warranty Length What’s Covered
Budget 5–10 years Limited sagging/defects
Mid-range 10–15 years Sagging, manufacturing
Premium 20+ years or lifetime Full coverage with conditions

6. What’s the return or exchange policy?

Inquire about the store’s return window, any restocking fees, and whether an exchange is possible. Some stores offer 30–100 night trials, but policies vary.

7. Do you offer sleep trials?

Sleep trials are essential for testing a mattress at home. Ask:

  • How long is the trial?

  • Can I return it for a full refund?

  • Are there return shipping or restocking fees?

8. Are there any ongoing promotions or discounts?

Don’t hesitate to ask about current sales, bundling options, or seasonal promotions. Many mattress stores run discounts, especially during holidays.

9. What are the delivery and setup options?

Clarify whether delivery is included, and if the team will:

  • Set up the mattress in your home

  • Remove your old mattress

  • Handle stairs or tight spaces

Ask for these details in writing if possible.

10. Can you provide product certifications or test results?

If you’re concerned about materials, emissions, or durability, ask for certifications like CertiPUR-US®, OEKO-TEX®, or GREENGUARD. A transparent store should easily provide this information.

How can I test a mattress in-store effectively?

Trying a mattress in-store is one of the most important parts of the buying process. You can read all the specs, but nothing replaces lying down on a bed to see how it truly feels. To get the most out of your testing experience, use a strategic approach.

1. Wear Comfortable Clothes

Before heading to the store, dress in casual, non-restrictive clothing. You’ll be lying on several mattresses, possibly changing positions often. Avoid bulky or stiff clothes that could interfere with your ability to gauge comfort.

2. Lie Down in Your Normal Sleep Position

Spend at least 10–15 minutes on each mattress, mimicking your typical sleep position—whether it’s on your back, side, stomach, or a mix. This gives your body time to respond to the surface and helps you detect any pressure points or discomfort.

3. Test Multiple Firmness Levels

Try soft, medium, and firm options even if you think you already know your preference. You might be surprised by what feels best in person. Some stores display a firmness scale (1–10) or let you adjust it on a test bed.

4. Move Around to Gauge Responsiveness

Roll over, switch sides, sit on the edge—anything you normally do in bed. This helps test motion transfer, bounce, and edge support. These are key factors, especially if you share the bed with a partner.

5. Ask for a Pillow

Bring your own pillow or ask the store for one similar to what you use at home. This ensures that the angle of your neck and spine is as close to your actual sleep setup as possible, which impacts how the mattress feels.

6. Check Pressure Relief and Support

Pay attention to how the mattress supports key areas like your shoulders, lower back, and hips. Use this checklist:

  • Side sleepers: Look for shoulder/hip contouring.

  • Back sleepers: Check lumbar support.

  • Stomach sleepers: Ensure no excessive sinkage at the hips.

7. Rate Each Mattress Immediately

After testing each mattress, rate it on a simple scale (e.g., 1 to 5) for comfort, support, and overall feel. Take notes or use your phone to record impressions while they’re fresh.

8. Compare Features and Materials

Ask about the materials in each mattress—foam types, coil count, edge reinforcement, cooling tech. Comparing these features helps explain why one mattress may feel better than another.

Here’s a basic feature comparison table:

Feature Mattress A Mattress B Mattress C
Firmness Level Medium Firm Soft
Coil Count 850 1000 None
Memory Foam Density 4 lbs/ft³ 5 lbs/ft³ 3 lbs/ft³
Cooling Technology Gel foam Phase-change Open cell

9. Try With a Partner (If Applicable)

If you sleep with a partner, mattress testing should be a team effort. Lie together, check for motion transfer, edge support, and how well the bed accommodates two bodies.

10. Trust Your Body Over Sales Pitches

Salespeople may have incentives to push certain models, but your comfort should guide the decision. Take your time, trust how your body feels, and don’t be swayed by pressure or flashy features you don’t need.

Conclusion

Shopping for a mattress is an important investment in your health, comfort, and quality of life. By understanding what to look for—such as the right type, firmness, sleep trial policies, material quality, and the expertise of salespeople—you can approach mattress stores with confidence and clarity. Taking the time to ask the right questions, test mattresses thoroughly in-store, and compare options based on your sleep habits and physical needs ensures that you make a choice that promotes restful, rejuvenating sleep. With a thoughtful approach and the insights from this guide, you’re well-equipped to find the perfect mattress that supports your lifestyle and long-term comfort.

About the author